IMF: Phasing Out Dutch Mortgage Interest Deduction Won’t Trigger Sharp House Price Collapse
The IMF argues that scrapping the Netherlands’ mortgage interest deduction will modestly dampen prices rather than cause a steep drop, provided it’s phased out gradually within a wider housing strategy.
NL Rental News
Table of Contents
Further Reading on Renting in the Netherlands
Housing and Healthcare Supersede Asylum as Top Concerns for Dutch Voters
Recent surveys reveal that the Dutch housing crisis and rising healthcare costs have overtaken asylum and immigration as the primary concerns for voters ahead of the next parliamentary elections.
NL Rental News
The True Cost of Buying a House in the Netherlands: Hidden Fees and Taxes Explained
Buying a home in the Netherlands involves more than the purchase price—learn about transfer tax, notary fees, mortgage advice costs, and more to budget correctly.
NL Rental News
4 Reasons to Partner with @WORK Makelaardij to Find Your Dutch Home
Discover why @WORK Makelaardij is the go-to real estate agency for expats and internationals looking to buy or rent in the Netherlands.
NL Rental News
Landlord Sell-Off Propels Q3 Home Sales to Highest Level in Almost Five Years
Third-quarter home sales in the Netherlands soared to their highest level since early 2021, driven by landlord and investor sell-offs of rental properties.
NL Rental News
Newest Properties in the Netherlands
Explore the latest properties added to Luntero. Find new apartments, houses, and studios across the Netherlands — updated daily to help you discover your next home faster.
Your Ultimate All-in-One Rental Search Tool for the Netherlands
Luntero consolidates rental apartments, rooms, studios, and houses from the leading Dutch real estate platforms (including Funda, Pararius) into a single, constantly updated database. Easily filter by price, number of bedrooms, pet policy, specific neighborhoods, and more to find your dream home in the Netherlands much faster.
Comprehensive Dutch Rental Listings
Discover every available rental property from Funda, Pararius, Kamernet, and more. Stop switching between multiple sites – no more missing out on hidden gems in the Dutch housing market.
Intuitive User-Friendly Interface
Navigate our clean and straightforward design effortlessly on both desktop and mobile devices for a seamless apartment, house, or room hunting experience in the Netherlands.
Multilingual Support for Expats & Locals
Browse rental listings in English, Dutch, Spanish, French, German, and more. Luntero ensures you can find your next home in the Netherlands in the language you're most comfortable with.
Real-Time Listing & Price Updates
Get instant notifications for new rental listings and price changes. Stay ahead of the competition in the dynamic Dutch rental market and secure your ideal home.
Understand Dutch rental terms before you sign the lease.
Renting in the Netherlands comes with unique rules, legal phrases, and housing abbreviations that can be tricky. The Luntero Rental Glossary is your guide to every rental term — from tenancy agreements, deposits, and agency fees to utility charges, rent control, and tenant rights. Whether you’re new to renting, moving as an expat, or just want to avoid hidden costs, our glossary helps you rent smarter, negotiate better, and protect yourself from mistakes.
IMF: Phasing Out Dutch Mortgage Interest Deduction Won’t Trigger Sharp House Price Collapse
The possibility of abolishing the mortgage interest deduction (MID) in the Netherlands has been a long-standing point of debate. While critics warn of a potential crash in house prices, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) believes that, if handled correctly, the tax change would temper—but not topple—the housing market. This article explores the IMF’s stance, the mechanics of the deduction, and why a gradual approach combined with broader housing measures can protect both homeowners and overall market stability.
Understanding the Mortgage Interest Deduction
Since the early 2000s, Dutch homeowners have benefited from the mortgage interest deduction, a tax break allowing borrowers to deduct paid interest from their taxable income. Intended to boost homeownership and make monthly payments more affordable, the policy has also been criticized for inflating house prices and widening the gap between the owner-occupied and rental sectors.
Key features of the MID:
Eligibility: Residents with a primary mortgage on an owner-occupied property.
Deduction rate: Gradually reduced over two decades, but still substantial for many borrowers.
Duration: Phasing down from perpetual eligibility to a capped term, though political consensus halted full abolition—until now.
IMF Perspective: Moderate Impact Over Time
At its annual meeting in Washington, IMF director Marnix van Rij stressed that eliminating the MID need not precipitate a market crash. He labeled the deduction a “distortion in the housing market” that tilts demand upward, yet emphasized that any reform must be gradual and form part of a broader policy toolkit.
“An abrupt end would produce shockwaves,” Van Rij explained, “but a phased removal spread over decades will cushion the impact and give households time to adjust.” His comments reflect the IMF’s long-standing recommendation to address market imbalances while safeguarding financial stability.
Will House Prices Plummet?
A recent study by Job Swank, former chief economist at De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB), suggested that an immediate stop to interest deductions on new loans could cause house prices to drop by up to 30% over ten years. Such a decline would erode homeowner equity and could ripple through bank balance sheets.
However, Van Rij argues that this scenario lacks political support. No major party is proposing a one-year cutoff. Instead, election manifestos range from 20- to 30-year phase-out plans, which soften the transition and spread costs across multiple electoral cycles.
Phasing Out vs. Abrupt Abolition
How the MID is removed matters more than if it’s removed. Two main pathways emerge:
Considerations: Requires sustained political will; complex tax code evolution.
Immediate End (1–2 years)
Advantages: Quick alignment with rental market; faster fiscal savings.
Risks: Sharp price corrections; homeowner wealth shock; potential bank stress.
Virtually no party supports an abrupt end. Instead, policymakers are focused on mechanisms that give both households and lenders adequate time to rebalance.
Using Proceeds to Offset Pain
Abolishing the MID frees up significant fiscal resources—estimated at around €11 billion annually. The IMF and former State Secretary Van Rij suggest redirecting these proceeds in ways that mitigate negative impacts:
Targeted Tax Relief: Lowering income tax rates for middle-income earners.
Housing Allowances: Expanding or adjusting huurtoeslag (housing benefit) for low-income renters.
Supply-Side Investments: Financing social housing projects with woningcorporaties (public housing associations) and municipalities (gemeenten) to speed up new construction.
Such measures can compensate homeowners for higher monthly costs, support vulnerable tenants, and tackle the root supply challenge that fuels price hikes.
Addressing the Housing Shortage
Beyond tax reform, the IMF underscores that boosting housing supply is crucial. The Netherlands faces a shortage of hundreds of thousands of homes, pushing up rents and sales prices alike. Key strategies include:
Streamlining planning procedures at the municipal level to accelerate building permits.
Incentivizing private developers through tax credits or land-use flexibility.
Strengthening partnership models between gemeenten and woningcorporaties to deliver affordable housing swiftly.
By combining MID reform with a robust construction agenda, authorities can strike a balance: cooling excessive demand while expanding the overall housing stock.
Looking Ahead: A Balanced Housing Policy
As the election season unfolds, parties must refine their MID phase-out trajectories and link them clearly to broader housing strategies. According to the IMF, success hinges on three pillars:
Communication: Clearly outline timelines, relief measures, and expected market effects.
Complementary Measures: Tie fiscal savings to tax relief or supply-side incentives.
Monitoring and Flexibility: Adjust the path based on economic conditions and housing market data.
A well-managed reform can promote sustainability, reduce market distortions, and ultimately foster a healthier relationship between renting and owning.
Ultimately, phasing out the mortgage interest deduction in the Netherlands need not trigger a housing market meltdown. With gradual implementation, reinvestment of proceeds, and a focus on boosting supply, policymakers can ensure that both homeowners and renters benefit from a more stable, equitable housing landscape.
Looking for your next rental in the Netherlands? Discover how easy it is to find trusted listings with Luntero.
Luntero Rental Glossary
Understand Dutch rental terms before you sign the lease.
Renting in the Netherlands comes with unique rules, legal phrases, and housing abbreviations that can be tricky. The Luntero Rental Glossary is your guide to every rental term — from tenancy agreements, deposits, and agency fees to utility charges, rent control, and tenant rights. Whether you’re new to renting, moving as an expat, or just want to avoid hidden costs, our glossary helps you rent smarter, negotiate better, and protect yourself from mistakes.
